Abandoning Dewey

As a librarian, of course, I get all the Dewey jokes (“are they still teaching that?!”) and mock-horror stories (“God, I don’t know why that’s still around!”). It’s still claimed to be the most widely used filing system for libraries in the world (200,000+ libraries) and, as a “language” of libraries, I still think it’s highly worth learning. I’m impressed that large public libraries like the SFPL use it to classify their 550 million+ volumes–that’s a lot of items to give only 999 categories to!

The “bulletproofness” of the systems definitely is not its Judeo-Christian, Euro-centric bent. Only the last section of the 200’s, the 290’s, are given over to classifying the rest of the world’s religions. And don’t get me started with literature in non-Latin languages (890’s) or history in Mexico and other central American societies (972). These number sets are just too small. Instead, libraries continue to use it more as an Esperanto, where it serves the needs of so many libraries, it’s convenient and well-documented, and there are, at least, tens of thousands libraries cataloging with it. Not to mentioned that it is owned and maintained by a non-profit dedicated to its survival.

Some libraries try and step outside of this system, such as the famous Hennepin County Library (who restructured their subject headings with “real world” applicability) and, now, Gilbert, Arizona’s public library (dropped the Dewey system altogether). It takes guts (and money, and time) to dump a common system that’s out of date…

One thought on “Abandoning Dewey

  1. Okay so I usually hate those old fuddy duddies who hate new fangled library things, like, you know, not microfilm or some other horror actually easy to use and useful to the user.

    But I love Dewey. It makes my little librarian heart sing. It can accomodate anything synthetically! And yes it’s totally racist and Eurocentric….but so much better than everything out there!

    Not that I wouldn’t love a stab at classification systems myself, but what library/system has the money and time to hire me (or anyone else)?! šŸ™‚

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s